Back in 2014, director Justin Simien
released the satirical comedy-drama "Dear White People." Praised upon
its release, many called it the year's best indie film. Fast forward to
mid-2016, it was announced that Netflix had acquired the rights to a show based
off the movie. After that the show went under the radar for a while, until its
first teaser anyways. In early 2017 Netflix released a 30 second teaser to
promote the show; but what has become standard practice soon turned into a
complete and utter sh*t show. The teaser was quickly called racist against
white people and received a massive amount of criticism and hate. Some were so
upset by the trailer that they even canceled their Netflix subscriptions. Now
in all honesty, it's a bad trailer. You see the central character (a black
woman who hosts a radio show) talking towards all of her white listeners that
blackface is not acceptable. A reasonable enough request, but the way the
trailer is cut together paints a picture that all white people are racist. I
consider myself to have thick skin, and while I don't think it was a great
trailer I was by no means offended like some where. So while many cried foul I
was indifferent. I don't think you should judge a show by its trailer, and from
what I heard it was not a good representation of the movie (which is a satire
that openly criticizes everyone, including the black community). So I decided
to wait for the finished product and see what it was really like. Turns out it
may be one of the year's best new shows.
Winchester
University is a prestigious Ivy League college that prides itself on being
forward thinking and inclusive, but many of small number of black students on
campus disagree with that position. While there are some disagreements on
campus over how the world is run, up until the school's satirical newspaper
decides to through a black-face party in protest of local radio host, Samantha
White's, radio show titled Dear White People. After that, sh*t hits the fan.
Following several students around campus, what follows is an amalgamation of
modern day life for people of color; and one white guy.
When that
first teaser trailer dropped a while back, I was unsure. I had heard great
things about the movie but the teaser looked like it was going to be a too
heavy handed for its own good. To my surprise, it's become one of my favorite
Netflix original shows. First off I have to commend how well written this show
is. The scripts are fantastic, filled with great dialog and memorable lines
spoken by interesting and colorful characters (all of which are played by
talented actors who give excellent performances). The show is intelligent; it's
satire that criticizes just about everyone. It does a great job integrating
relevant social comedy into an otherwise very funny show. Due to the show's
interesting and original premise, it manages to always be entertaining; I don't
think I walked away from this first season thinking any given episode was bad.
Despite that, the show has a few flaws. While a clever satire, I couldn't help
but feel that the show becomes too self-indulgent at times. What could have
been clever, but subdued themes, were too on the nose. The problem is that many
of the issues discussed in this show, while still timely and relevant, where
more in the forefront when the movie came out. Since the release of the movie
we've seen countless shows and movies address many of the topics and issues
brought up in this show. And it's less subtle and clever than a few of those
other properties. So while it may have a few issues, I walked away from this
series in love. Not only is it one of the best movies to TV adaptations I've
ever seen, I think it may be one of Netflix's best original comedies to date.
If you are easily offended in any way shape or form, this show probably isn't
for you. But if you're in the market for good television, the first season of
"Dear White People" is fantastic.
Pros: Well written scripts, interesting and colorful characters, great acting from the entire cast, intelligent satire that criticizes all, original premise, very funny, always entertaining, relevant social commentary, one of Netflix's best comedies to date, fantastic movie to TV adaptation.
Cons: Feels a bit too self-indulgent at times, a little too on the nose at times.
No comments:
Post a Comment